There we are sitting by the water
Our first date, didn’t know what we started
And it felt like a dream, like we were meant to be I was falling so hard for you
I was hoping you could feel it too
Then you looked right at me
You took out two pennies
And said “Let’s make a wish.”

CHORUS
I wish we’d last forever
Always be together
Never had to say goodbye
We would never give up
This love was strong enough
I know I’m asking a lot
But please just give me this wish

Time went on, we were still going strong
Like that night you danced with me in that sparkly gown And it felt like a movie
I hope that it has a happy ending
Lying here in your arms
I feel safe and Heaven doesn’t feel so far
I said, “Look at the clock, it’s 11:11 so let’s make a wish.”

CHORUS

I ask you, “Do you remember that day we threw our Pennies in the water and made our wishes together?”
You said, “Yes, how could I forget? That was the best day.” Then I asked you, “What did you wish for?”
You said

CHORUS